In any business my first question is who earns and who pays for the mistake. Here the channels earned views and new subscribers. The payers were elsewhere: police with smashed vehicles, the National Guard with a wrecked bus, and servicemen who, according to their command, now have to be relocated, because the address is known to the whole country and not only to it.
All of us paid too, because one more crack opened between civilians and the military. An enemy could not have bought that crack at any price.
There are no two camps in this for me. A Ukrainian serviceman has to be protected by law from a crowd and from arbitrariness inside the system alike. If somebody was beaten, those responsible answer. If this was a plant, the people who launched it answer. Neither sentence cancels the other.
The tension underneath it is not only ours. I work a great deal in France, where a country can catch fire in a single evening; in Germany and Italy relatives and neighbours fall out over politics and migration. The difference is slack. Europe has time and a margin we do not. We are living inside a war, and our string is pulled far tighter.
So I am left with two questions rather than a conclusion. The first: the cyber-war is not in its first year. Does the state hold a capability effective, professional and accountable enough to stop a crisis like this before it turns physical? That evening it was not visible. Who noticed that one person had become forty in half an hour? Who checked the source? Who told people the truth within the hour? And who answers if none of that happened? Without censorship, without pursuing people, and without the habit of calling any inconvenient criticism enemy propaganda — information security does not begin with banning questions. It begins with a state able to answer them quickly and honestly.
The second is for everyone who writes for hundreds of thousands of readers. The problems are real and have to be named, corruption exposed, justice demanded. But negativity sells better, and a frightening headline collects more views than a calm account. You do not know who is reading you at two in the morning — a soldier after a bad day, a mother in her third week without word from her son. I am not asking anyone to hide the truth. I am asking that hopelessness not be sold as the only truth on offer.